I agree the original trilogy just kind of handwaves a lot of its worldbuilding, which is a similarity that it shares with the sequels. But yeah, it's bewildering when we have this massive setup in the OT and prequels that the current situation doesn't really connect with. With the OT before the prequels came out, I was just like--'I guess that's just how it is for them then' because there was no existing context to contradict most of the narrative devices and one could just imagine a large number of things that didn't fundamentally contradict the narrative. And then the prequels connects *very* closely with the OT.
But for the sequels it's like nothing from the previous movies tells us how the current situation came to be, and in order to understand it you *have* to consume the ancillary media. And even then I guess you have to consume more of it than I have because I am still ??? on so many things despite having read several of the Disney canon novels already. I suspect some of it has never even been addressed at all. I wanted them to actually pull more story threads from the original trilogy and prequels and connect to those to the narrative of the prequels and sequels. It feels very 'now buy these five thousand DLCs to complete the story!' to me.
And that's an interesting criticism of Rey which I haven't heard before but I think I agree with! Her motivations do tend to feel very 'because plot'. She had to try to go back to Jakku to create narrative conflict with co-protagonist Finn, then she decides to join the Resistance and abandon waiting for her family on the word of a random old woman she's just met. Then she does a complete 180 on Kylo in a super-short time period from being tortured by him and trying to kill him to trying to redeem him and just trusting whatever he says with absolutely zero skepticism. All of this advances the plot but it doesn't really come from her character. It would've been nice if her personality and behavior reflected her background and experiences better rather than it feeling like her character just gets yanked into doing whatever whenever it's convenient for the writer. They still could have made the things the wanted to happen occur but made it feel like the narrative had earned that reaction from her. Though I also think it might be interesting if she had made some choices differently.
no subject
But for the sequels it's like nothing from the previous movies tells us how the current situation came to be, and in order to understand it you *have* to consume the ancillary media. And even then I guess you have to consume more of it than I have because I am still ??? on so many things despite having read several of the Disney canon novels already. I suspect some of it has never even been addressed at all. I wanted them to actually pull more story threads from the original trilogy and prequels and connect to those to the narrative of the prequels and sequels. It feels very 'now buy these five thousand DLCs to complete the story!' to me.
And that's an interesting criticism of Rey which I haven't heard before but I think I agree with! Her motivations do tend to feel very 'because plot'. She had to try to go back to Jakku to create narrative conflict with co-protagonist Finn, then she decides to join the Resistance and abandon waiting for her family on the word of a random old woman she's just met. Then she does a complete 180 on Kylo in a super-short time period from being tortured by him and trying to kill him to trying to redeem him and just trusting whatever he says with absolutely zero skepticism. All of this advances the plot but it doesn't really come from her character. It would've been nice if her personality and behavior reflected her background and experiences better rather than it feeling like her character just gets yanked into doing whatever whenever it's convenient for the writer. They still could have made the things the wanted to happen occur but made it feel like the narrative had earned that reaction from her. Though I also think it might be interesting if she had made some choices differently.