Problems of Past and Present
Feb. 20th, 2023 03:12 pmI don't think medieval Europe was some amazing utopia and I very much would not want to live there myself, but in many ways, it was probably more just, fair, and equitable than the modern world. Individuals had more power over their daily lives, and despotic feudal lords would only start and not finish the process of enclosure towards the end of this period. People couldn't be so closely surveilled or as easily controlled as they are today, and vast tracts of nature still existed. While medical care was much more basic than what is available today, medicinal substances could be easily grown and medicine wasn't being gatekept by prescriptions or a War on Drugs. There's definitely places I'd rather be in this time period than Europe, but I think even there I'd have a chance.
Would just have to be ready to run if I saw a mob coming at me with pitchforks. Oh, and also be ready to die of Black Plague or sepsis.
While there's a tendency to glorify the past, there's also a tendency to glorify the present as if it has overcome all the issues of the past rather than simply expressing many of them in a different form and also creating new issues that would previously have been unimaginable.
This is why I don't agree with statements about how the world is experiencing unprecedented peace and prosperity or how technology only increases our standard of living. Microwaves aren't, and can't, make this world a utopia--only people can do that. Only justice can do that.
ramble tags: harmful optimism, is optimism that refuses to acknowledge harm