unspeakablehorror: (Default)

The thing about Land Back is that it really is quite literal. The land must be returned to indigenous populations and they must have the authority to make decisions about land management. Cessation of violence against them is a necessary but not sufficient component of this.

And an essential component of decolonization is Land Back. Without Land Back any talk of decolonization is really quite meaningless.  A key component of the colonizer mentality is the assumption that this means they will be forced to leave the land or will be genocided or severely mistreated. This is a form of projection, because colonizers do not only mistreat the people of the lands they occupy: they also mistreat diasporic populations in the lands they are native to (or occupy) and refugees.

While there are no perfect people in this world, it is in fact quite possible to live with others not like oneself without turning them out of their homes, subjugating, or genociding them. Thus the rejoinder of 'well they would do it to me otherwise so I need to do it first' simply has no merit. If a serial killer who brutally murdered people simply going about their day tried to argue that their actions were justified because otherwise those people would have done the same to them, I would never seriously consider that a valid argument. I don't think a court of law would either. But far too many accept the same logic when it comes to colonialism.

unspeakablehorror: (Default)

I think a very important thing to understand about decolonization is that it's not a call for the colonizer to leave and 'go back home', whatever in the world that's supposed to mean.

Which is to say that no, decolonization doesn't mean, say, United States citizens whose great-great-great grandparents were British get shipped back to Britain when the Native Americans get their rights back. It doesn't mean that if one of your parents is native and one is from France they tear you half and half of you goes to France while the other half stays in Missouri. It doesn't even mean that if you immigrated here yesterday that you have to go back to the country you left. It doesn't mean that white Mexicans get sent back to Spain. And it doesn't mean Israelis have to leave their homes for Palestinians to be free.

What decolonization means is to end the apartheid, subjugation, murder, and genocide of indigenous people. To return the sovereignty of the land back to indigenous people. I also think that we may also have to give up the modern conception of a country--that the very idea of what a nation is needs to be able to accomodate the idea of nations whose lands overlap, even if their people answer to separate governing bodies. But regardless of how governance is assigned to land, I think that ultimately the people who make decisions about the land should be the people living there, not corporations and governments who only care to extract as much as possible from the land before turning it into a lifeless husk.

But I think one obstacle to ending the colonialist nightmare of the modern world is that so much of colonialism is about teaching people to think of others in terms of zero sum transactions--any gain to another must be a loss to yourself. But ultimately, I think the opposite is true--in destroying the world for others, we also ultimately destroy it for ourselves. And eventually the colonialist will see little choice but to focus more and more of their destructive energies on eradicating their own. After all, if they don't subjugate and kill you first, you would surely do the same to them. You're either with them or against them.  You're lesser than them, less intelligent, less noble, more violent. This omnicidal logic is the end stage of colonialism's zero-sum game.

Change may be frightening, and there is much we would have to work out to make things work. But the consequences of continuing on our current course are unimaginably worse.


Profile

unspeakablehorror: (Default)
unspeakablehorror

February 2026

S M T W T F S
123 4567
8 9 1011 121314
15161718192021
2223 2425262728

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Tag Cloud

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Feb. 26th, 2026 11:53 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios