unspeakablehorror: (Default)

A little over halfway through the novel now. So one thing you get to see in the Dispossessed is people both living in and arguing for different political and economic systems. Which despite the didacticism, is still a nice change of pace from most science fiction, which usually keeps such concerns secondary or else in line with government propaganda.  This can be unintentional at times, but regardless of the intention, it tends to promote uncritical acceptance of our unimaginably violent status quo. The Dispossessed doesn't do this. It might seem strange that I consider the didacticism a negative quality given my interest in the political and economic themes--however I disagree that such ideas need to be presented in a dry or didactic way. I think if one wants to primarily teach, nonfiction is a much better medium for that. I feel stories are better at spurring us to ask better questions than they are at giving us answers to those questions.
 

Read more... )

 

unspeakablehorror: (Default)

Well, I finally finished reading The Left Hand of Darkness by Ursula K. Le Guin.  I'd started it years ago and gotten perhaps 80 pages in before I stopped.  I had a much easier time getting into it this time around.  I found it interesting and thoughtful, though the over half-century between now and when it was written certainly shows.  I think that even stories that try to imagine cultures starkly different from their own as this one does still can never quite escape their own in ways that may be quite subtle to those in that time and place, but quite obvious to those outside it.  Though I will say that of the books I have read from LeGuin, she is the sci-fi and fantasy author I've seen make the most effort to reimagine culture.  

It's simply that I can still see the bones of that culture, that time and place, even here in this alien world and especially in this human who hails from what would still be an unimaginable society to us, seeking as it does only trade and companionship with other worlds, and not control or domination.  I think all stories are, to some extent, rooted to the culture they arise out of, as we can never entirely understand what we dwell within.  But this is a larger attempt to dwell outside that culture than other sci-fi I've seen, from any time period.

I don't know if it's supposed to be incomprehensible, but I never could understand why Genly distrusted Estraven for so long, and it meant I found him quite unlikeable for a good portion of the story.  Naturally my favorite character was Estraven.

I had also been under the false impression based on what others had said about this story  that there was sex in this novel. There is no sex in this novel. Just aliens who go into heat.  On a frigid cold planet. With a human who is always cold there, and sometimes must huddle, naked, with those aliens for warmth. Who is sometimes completely alone with their dearest friend, who is in heat.  This is, I think, a very important thing to understand about this novel. 

Anyway, I was glad to finally finish this story.  I found it much easier to read through on my second attempt.

Profile

unspeakablehorror: (Default)
unspeakablehorror

May 2025

S M T W T F S
    1 23
45 678 910
111213141516 17
1819 2021 222324
25262728293031

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Tag Cloud

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated May. 29th, 2025 06:40 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios